REVIEWS
Closing out her ‘Over It’ trilogy, the R&B singer fully claims her narrative in a powerful, radiant step forward.
Summer Walker has spent more than five years shaping a trilogy of albums that trace heartbreak, desire, and complicated love with intoxicating detail. Whether you connected with the vulnerable honesty of 2019’s ‘Over It’ or with 2021’s ‘Still Over It’ and its ability to turn heartache into alt R and B magic, the twenty nine year old singer has created records that stand confidently among modern R and B’s defining works. And on ‘Finally Over It’, the last chapter in the trilogy, Walker sounds free in a way she never has before, no longer weighed down by the shadows of her public breakups.
Walker, who has held the R and B world captivated with deeply personal, lived in lyrics set against lush and seductive production, has often been seen as a tragic figure, not unlike the late Anna Nicole Smith, whom she channels on the cover art. From the moment the violins open disc one, the “For Better” section, you expect her to unleash intense, unfiltered emotion, placing her heart directly into your hands and commanding your attention with her velvety voice. She delivers on that expectation, even if some of the featured guests hold her back.
‘Robbed You’ attempts to capture the sweet but dangerous edge of the ‘Over It’ standout ‘I’ll Kill You’, but instead of being so in love that she would harm her partner if he left, Walker sings in her familiar fiery tone about being so angry after the breakup that robbing him might have been more satisfying. Where Jhene Aiko blended perfectly into ‘I’ll Kill You’, Mariah The Scientist’s flat presence dulls what could have been a standout moment.
We also miss out on a true girl anthem with ‘Go Girl’. Walker’s rap delivery is sluggish, Latto does not find her footing in the relaxed production, and Doja Cat enters too late to rescue the track’s sleepy energy. But ‘Baby’ with Chris Brown becomes the most divisive choice. Brown’s doubled vocals on the chorus lack spark and waste the chance to properly use the sample of Mariah Carey’s ‘Always Be My Baby’, yet the melody is so smooth and hypnotic that you may find yourself swaying despite your hesitation, making it a strange but somewhat effective twist.
If you push through that section, disc two, the “For Worse” part, offers a reward with more layered and honest emotional territory. The playful ‘How Sway’ with SAILORR gives a clever spin to the famous Kanye West meme through the warm shimmer of classic R and B. Walker and Brent Faiyaz continue their reign as the King and Queen of toxic slow jams with ‘Number One’. And we finally get the girl anthem we have been waiting for on ‘Baller’, where GloRilla, Sexyy Red, and Monaleo bring their own flair and boldness, creating a fast paced celebration of feminine strength and personality.
‘Stitch Me Up’ stands out as the album’s most powerful ballad: an unfiltered, personal cry for help turned into a shared emotional release, carried by aching guitar and crashing cymbals. “I know that it’s wrong, but that’s how I was taught,” Walker admits, “Gave my heart once before, and all it got was torn.” The song captures the emotional core of the entire ‘Over It’ trilogy. Love has never been simple for Walker. Every breakup has played out publicly, amplified across social media, forcing her to break and rebuild herself over and over while the world watched. But now, she has reclaimed her power. Where Anna Nicole was denied peace, Walker has traded sorrow for self determination, and at last, she can truly be over it.